The holiday season is fast approaching, and there’s no better time to launch your own e-commerce shop. Whether you’re selling custom apparel, home decor, or unique accessories, using a print-on-demand (POD) service like Printful or Printify can streamline the process, allowing you to focus on marketing and sales while these platforms handle printing and fulfillment.
But which service should you choose for your shop? Both Printful and Printify offer competitive features, and selecting the right one can be the difference between a smooth, profitable holiday season and a stressful one. In this post, we’ll break down the features of each platform, compare them in a side-by-side chart, and help you decide which service is best for your holiday shop.
What is Printful?
Printful is a print-on-demand fulfillment service that allows you to sell custom designs on products like t-shirts, hoodies, mugs, and posters. Printful handles everything from printing and packaging to shipping. It integrates with popular e-commerce platforms like Shopify, Etsy, and WooCommerce.
I use Printful for one of my businesses and I really like it. I like the selection of products and that the affiliate program is built into the same app you use for your catalog. You don't have to leave the platform in order to get to the link. That saves time and keeps everything organized.
Printful’s Key Features:
No upfront costs: You only pay for the product and printing once an order is placed.
High-quality products: Known for premium product quality, especially apparel.
Fast fulfillment: Printful has fulfillment centers across the globe, leading to shorter shipping times.
Customization: Offers branding options like custom labels, inserts, and packaging.
Design tools: Printful’s built-in design maker allows you to easily create mockups.
Integrations: Seamlessly integrates with major e-commerce platforms and marketplaces.
What is Printify?
Printify is another print-on-demand service that connects shop owners with a network of suppliers who print and fulfill products. Printify stands out by giving you access to a variety of print providers, which means you can choose the best option for each product in terms of quality, price, and shipping location.
I also use Printify for one of my other businesses and as an affiliate marketer not having a full on affiliate program within the platform is a painpoint. There is a simple referral program built in that's actually a little hard to find unless you're looking for it. You have to go under wallet, then rewards. Sounds simple but most affiliate programs are clearly marked. This one just gives $20 per referral. I'd like to see an actual affiliate program where earnings potentials are greater.
Printify’s Key Features:
Global network of suppliers: Access to multiple print providers allows for competitive pricing and quicker shipping options based on location.
Affordable pricing: Printify offers lower base prices on many products, giving sellers higher profit margins.
Wide product range: Printify offers over 600 products, including apparel, accessories, and home goods.
Free and premium plans: While the basic plan is free, Printify offers a paid Premium plan with a 20% discount on all products.
Multiple printing options: Choose different printing techniques like direct-to-garment (DTG), embroidery, and sublimation.
Integrations: Like Printful, Printify integrates with major e-commerce platforms, making it easy to list products and sync orders.
Comparing Printful vs. Printify
To help you make an informed decision, here’s a side-by-side comparison of the two platforms:
Feature | Printful | Printify |
Pricing | Free, pay for fulfillment when an order is placed | Free for Basic, $29/month for Premium Plan |
Product Range | ~200 products (apparel, accessories, home decor) | ~600 products (apparel, accessories, home goods) |
Supplier Network | In-house fulfillment centers (Europe, USA, Mexico) | Access to multiple suppliers worldwide |
Product Pricing | Higher base prices for premium quality | Lower base prices, varies by supplier |
Fulfillment Time | 2-7 business days depending on location | Varies by supplier, can be faster with local suppliers |
Shipping Costs | Calculated per product and destination | Varies by supplier, some offer cheaper options |
Customization Options | Custom labels, packaging, and branding options | Limited customization options, depends on the supplier |
Integrations | Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, Amazon, eBay, etc. | Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, eBay, etc. |
Customer Support | 24/7 live chat, email, and phone support | Email and chat support, more limited response times |
Branding | Offers custom packaging, inserts, and white-label service | No custom packaging, white-label depends on the supplier |
Design Tools | Built-in mockup generator with detailed previews | Basic mockup generator |
Who is Printful Best For?
1. High-Quality Focused Sellers
If product quality and brand presentation are top priorities, Printful may be the better choice. Printful is known for premium-quality products and detailed mockups, making it ideal for small business owners who want to create a strong brand image.
2. Smaller Shops or Those Prioritizing Speed
If you’re only offering a small selection of products, Printful’s smaller catalog may work in your favor, allowing you to focus on core items. Additionally, Printful’s global fulfillment centers provide faster shipping options to international customers, which is a huge advantage for the holiday season.
3. Branding and Customization Needs
Printful offers more customization options, including personalized packaging and branded inserts. This makes it ideal if you want to create a cohesive and professional unboxing experience that elevates your brand and leaves a lasting impression on customers.
Who is Printify Best For?
1. Price-Conscious Sellers
If you’re looking to maximize profit margins, Printify’s lower product pricing and multiple supplier options allow you to choose the most cost-effective options. This is particularly beneficial if you’re selling in high volume or offering a wide variety of products.
2. Sellers with Large Product Catalogs
Printify offers a much larger range of products, with over 600 items in its catalog. If you plan to sell a wide range of custom products for the holidays, including unique items like home goods or niche apparel, Printify’s extensive options are perfect.
3. International Sellers
If your customer base is spread across different regions, Printify’s network of suppliers allows you to select fulfillment centers closest to your customers, potentially reducing shipping times and costs.
How to Choose the Right Platform for Your Holiday Shop
As the holiday season approaches, timing and efficiency are key to a successful launch. Here are a few questions to consider before choosing between Printful and Printify:
What is your product focus?
What is your priority: speed, quality, or price?
For fast shipping and premium-quality products, go with Printful. But if pricing is more important to you (especially if you’re running holiday promotions), Printify’s lower base costs may be the way to go.
How important is branding?
If you want your brand to stand out with custom packaging and a unique unboxing experience, Printful’s branding options will give you the upper hand. Printify has fewer branding options and relies on third-party suppliers, which means less control over packaging.
Do you need local suppliers?
Printify’s supplier network can be a huge advantage if you want to target customers in specific regions and ship from local providers to minimize costs and delivery times.
Preparing for the Holiday Rush
Regardless of whether you choose Printful or Printify, it’s important to get your shop up and running as soon as possible. The holiday season is fast-paced, and consumers will be looking for unique gifts and custom products. Here are a few tips to ensure your holiday shop is a success:
Optimize Your Product Listings: Write clear, concise product descriptions, use high-quality images, and make sure your store is SEO-friendly to attract organic traffic.
Start Marketing Early: Use email marketing, social media, and paid ads to build excitement for your products leading up to Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
Keep Shipping Times in Mind: The holidays can lead to longer shipping times, so be transparent with your customers about fulfillment and delivery expectations.
Offer Holiday Discounts: Everyone loves a good deal during the holidays. Consider offering limited-time discounts or bundling products to attract more customers.
Conclusion
Both Printful and Printify are excellent platforms for starting a print-on-demand shop in time for the holiday season. Your choice will ultimately depend on your specific business needs. If branding, quality, and speed are your main concerns, Printful is likely the better option. If you’re focused on affordability, product variety, and international reach, Printify is your best bet.
By making the right choice, you’ll set your holiday shop up for success, allowing you to focus on marketing, growing your business, and spreading holiday cheer to your customers!
Are you using Printful or Printify? Comment below.
Comments